Reality: cooking time is really restricted on Thanksgiving. You have got to in some way suit a turkey in your oven, make mashed potatoes and gravy, provide a pie and put the other amazing sides on the table. How will you do it?!

Do not worry, I have bought a resolution: wonderful sluggish cooker mashed potatoes! It’s a activity changer and frankly, I was shocked when they arrived out accurately the way I needed them to: creamy, smooth, tasty and total of flavor.

This recipe was motivated by my mother in law, who is known for creating the most creamy delicious mashed potatoes in the course of Thanksgiving. She often does anything a tiny unique, but my most favourite is when she adds just a small butter and sour product and then mashes them to perfection.

I tried using my greatest to replicate her recipe on the web site but retained it lightened up, and I imagine they are well value attempting. So creamy, so delectable!

Free Final Thanksgiving Guidebook (+ printable checklist!)

No matter if you’re web hosting or just attending, this Greatest Thanksgiving Information email sequence is for all people. Enter your electronic mail under to get all of my most effective recipes, recommendations, and a Cost-free printable checklist for all of your Thanksgiving requirements.

Components for sluggish cooker mashed potatoes

These easy crock pot mashed potatoes use minimal substances but switch out so creamy and delightful. You are going to will need:

  • Yukon gold potatoes: I imagine gold potatoes give the best, buttery texture and flavor, but you could also use russet potatoes. On the lookout for a sweet potato alternative? Attempt my Brown Butter Mashed Sweet Potatoes.
  • Garlic: get all of that savory, delightful flavor from 6 cloves of garlic. Of course, six!
  • Butter: what are mashed potatoes without a great deal of butter?! Come to feel free of charge to use salted or unsalted butter, and even vegan butter.
  • Broth or drinking water: add the fantastic quantity of moisture with hen broth, vegetable broth or drinking water.
  • Milk: I also like to add creaminess with unsweetened almond milk, but feel totally free to use any milk you’d like. If you are discovering that your mashed potatoes are much too thick immediately after cooking or sitting for a bit, truly feel cost-free to insert additional!
  • Bitter cream or greek yogurt: the key ingredient for silky crock pot mashed potatoes is sour product or greek yogurt.
  • Seasonings: do not forget to include plenty of salt and pepper to style. I also like to garnish with new thyme sprigs or even chives!

potatoes and garlic in a crock pot

How to make mashed potatoes in the slow cooker

In order to simplify the method and preserve a minimal time on Thanksgiving day I made a decision to choose my mom in law’s mashed potato recipe and make it in the gradual cooker for relieve! They arrived out magnificently flavorful and silky easy in just a handful of simple actions and with some uncomplicated suggestions:

  1. Mix potatoes, garlic & broth. You will start out by adding your diced, uncooked potatoes to your gradual cooker with the minced garlic and a small broth. No need to have to boil the potatoes beforehand! Change your sluggish cooker to significant to cook the potatoes. The broth will stop the potatoes from sticking to the bowl of the gradual cooker and will allow the potatoes to steam while they cook.
  2. Add creamy elements. Soon after the potatoes have been cooking in your crock pot and are very fork tender (4 hours on significant was excellent for mine!) include in the sour cream or greek yogurt, butter, a small milk to get started, salt & pepper.
  3. Mash ’em up. You’ll then want to mash every thing together with a potato masher. I do not advocate utilizing an electric powered mixture since there are a lot of potatoes and they may possibly go just about everywhere.
  4. Alter flavors & textures. All people enjoys their potatoes a little in different ways, so you can truly adjust below as you see suit. Incorporate further milk to make the potatoes creamier or sense free of charge to insert in much more butter and use entire milk for richer, ultra creamy mashed potatoes.
  5. Keep in mind to have enjoyment & appreciate! This recipe is quick and quite unachievable to mess up. Do not pressure far too substantially about it. When all accomplished and your potatoes are creamy and flavor delectable, basically scoop into a warm bowl right prior to serving, then garnish with a pat of butter and freshly ground black pepper on prime. YUM.

crock pot mashed potatoes in the bowl of a crock pot with a wooden spoon

Lighten them up to perfection

To make healthful crock pot mashed potatoes, I propose making use of unsweetened almond milk and whole milk greek yogurt in this recipe. You can also use vegan butter! Believe in me, they are nonetheless going to be extremely flavorful, silky and delectable. If you can also feel cost-free to use skim or 2% milk!

Peeling vs not peeling potatoes

In this recipe, you can possibly choose to peel your potatoes or depart the skins on. It just depends on how you like your mashed potato texture. I also like to preserve the skin on the potatoes, considering that I believe it provides a good texture, but truly feel no cost to peel them if you want an even smoother, creamier version.

easy slow cooker mashed potatoes with butter in a bowl with a spoon

Guidelines for producing the Greatest mashed potatoes

  • Be positive to generously season your mashed potatoes with salt and pepper and then blend all over again and style a bite or two prior to serving.
  • Insert supplemental milk to make the potatoes creamier or really feel free to add in far more butter and use entire milk for richer, ultra creamy mashed potatoes.
  • It is vital to flavor as you go, introducing a lot more of this and that the place needed. Experiencing is what cooking is all about, discovering to have faith in you and changing flavors.
  • If you like chunkier mashed potatoes, basically keep again on mashing them also much and leave some far more chunks!
  • Looking to use sweet potatoes? Consider my brown butter mashed sweet potato recipe below!

Preserving mashed potatoes heat in the sluggish cooker

Once your mashed potatoes are carried out cooking in the sluggish cooker and you have mashed them, you can convert the sluggish cooker to heat and retain on heat for up to 3 hours. Ahead of serving, I advise tasting them yet again and stirring in a very little extra milk to continue to keep them creamy, if necessary.

slow cooker mashed potatoes with butter in a bowl

Make them ahead of time

Of course, you can even make these effortless crock pot mashed potatoes in advance of time! You can both:

  • Cube up your potatoes 1 day ahead of time and retailer them in the fridge in a bowl of chilly water until you are completely ready to prepare dinner.
  • Or thoroughly cook the slow cooker mashed potatoes 1-2 days in advance of time and retailer them in an airtight container in the fridge. Then only increase them back to the slow cooker to reheat — including far more milk as needed.

Additional Thanksgiving recipes to try

Really feel free to verify out our Thanksgiving recipes in this article. Right here are some of my other own favorites:

I hope you really like these creamy gradual cooker mashed potatoes. They are straightforward, so Superior and a amazing way to help you save the two time and space all through Thanksgiving. Permit me know if you make this recipe by rating the recipe and leaving a comment beneath — xo!

Recipe by: Evi Madison // SRCooking | Images by: Take in Really like Eats

This submit was originally released on November 23, 2020, and republished on November 23, 2021.